Scam or just worst kind of telesales…
My husband, Mark and I share an office although we each run our own business. Yesterday Mark got an unexpected telephone call offering a ‘foolproof’ way to drive traffic to his militaria collectibles website (www.tigercollectibles.co.uk) and I’m almost convinced it was some type of phishing call – effectively a scam.
You see when he told me what the caller had said to him my first reaction was “That’s a load of rubbish”.
But then I thought about it a bit more and now I’m concerned that there might be more behind it. Here’s the gist of how the conversation went – see if you get the same impression I did.
Caller: “You know the display adverts that appear on the right side of your browser when you use Google to search for something?”
Mark:“Yes”
Caller: “Well we have the exclusive rights for the search terms Luftwaffe Collectibles and RAF Collectibles . For just £185 we can set it up so your website displays exclusively for those terms whenever anybody uses them to search on Google. And you can have that exclusivity for 12 months with an option to renew after 12 months. Would you like me to get that organised for you?”
Mark: “I’ll have a think about it.”
The caller explained the whole proposal again and asked if Mark would like to go ahead – he did this another twice! (Talk about pushy!!) and each time Mark said
“I understand what you’ve explained and, as I said, I’ll think about it. I’m not going to make a snap decision.”
Caller: “Right, can I have your full name?”
Mark: “I haven’t said I’m going to take up your offer so why do you need my full name?”
Caller: “This is a golden opportunity to get exclusive rights to those particular search terms and it’s for a full 12 months. How would you make your payment, by card? Can I have your card details then I can get it set up and call you back in an hour to let you know it is up and working?”
Mark: “No, I’m not going to give you my card details, I want to have a think about it.”
Caller: “Well, how long will it take you to decide?”
Mark: “You can call back on Friday and I’ll tell you my decision then.”
Caller: “OK, I’ll call you on Friday.”
Mark is not very technical and uses his computer purely to create his collectibles catalogue and answer incoming emails. All the other ‘techy’ stuff is taken care of for him. When he told me what had been said I explained that no-one can claim exclusive rights to a search term for a PPC (pay-per-click) advert. In fact, it is something he could have set up at any time if he wants.
But as I thought more about it I did wonder if someone who is not familiar with the way Google Adwords and other PPC advertising works could be duped into giving out their personal and credit card details. So was this really a phishing scam?
I did a 1471 (for those outside the UK dialing 1471 gives the number of the person who just called you if it wasn’t withheld) and got the caller’s number. When I rang back (I wanted to check which company was making this unbelievable offer) there was no answer.
Have you had any calls like this where someone you’ve never heard of tries to get you to give your card details over the phone for something they are apparently selling?
Do you think I’m being paranoid here? Was it a scam or was it just a very badly trained, pushy tele-sales person?
Hmm… it will be interesting to see if he does phone back tomorrow (Friday 13th). As they say ‘watch this space…’
~ Carol Bentley








24th May 2011 at 6:08 pm
Hi Janis – if it’s any consolation I’m also an impulse buyer and I have to rein in my enthusiasm sometimes – but rarely with phone calls like this.
23rd May 2011 at 6:30 am
Weeww! People I trust always tell me that those who ask for MONEY first are really up to something fishy. But man, I get fooled sometimes because I get persuaded perhaps, more easily then others. Because of that, I admire your husband for being so firm!
Thanks for sharing your story here.
5th October 2010 at 6:55 pm
Hi Diane,
They never do want to admit to it do they?
Even with sponsored ads they couldn’t guarantee a permanent fixed position because that’s not the way Google Ads works anyway!
BTW – we never did get a call back.
5th October 2010 at 2:54 pm
I get regular calls every week from various people telling me they are working with Google and can arrange to have my name on the sponsored ads for £400! I tell them my name is already at the top of the Google page, I put it there myself for nothing and they tell me theirs would be permanent and not get moved around. I tell them mine doesn’t move around and this is a scam isn’t it? They then deny it and I hang up. But try finding someone to complain to at Google; it’s almost as though they are reluctant to deal with the public, to whom they owe their existence and their customer service is very bad for such a high profile organisation. These sales people may not be connected with them, but it’s in Google’s interests to put a stop to it because as a result I would never advertise with any of Google’s schemes as it reflects badly on them, particularly when you can’t find a contact at Google to speak to. Today’s number came from 0161 260 0120. That’s a Manchester number! Well I’ve wasted enough time on them. Next time I’ll leave my phone off the hook.
29th March 2010 at 6:03 pm
Hi Roger
I totally understand how intensely irritating that was for you. These types of calls certainly make me steam!
I seriously doubt the call was from Google – probably someone trying to use Google’s credibility to their own advantage. And, based on your description, I’m also wondering if it is the company Paul very wisely dumped as an employer.
I’m so glad you have a policy of not buying from cold-calls and didn’t get bamboozled – you can see how people could get bullied into accepting this ‘offer’ and regretting it afterwards.
~ Carol
29th March 2010 at 2:55 pm
Hi All, I have just found this site in a Google search in an attempt to phone Google to make a complaint about a telesales pitch I have just received from ‘Google’?, interestingly, from a very rude Mancunian. I have now decided its a waste of time even trying to contact Google from other sites/forum’s I have found, and I have calmed down a little now. I am a relatively new driving Instructor, and thus new to internet advertising, and this guy, phoned me to try and sell me a ‘sponsored’ link to my web site for only £195 for the first month and £99 a month after, promising me top ranking in Google searched etc etc. I don’t buy anything from cold call selling at the best of times, but this guy wouldn’t take no for an answer. I tried to be polite and say I had spent my advertising budget for the next month, so he came back saying ‘you mean to tell me you haven’t got 99 quid!,,, I’ll phone someone who has got 99 quid then!’, before I could vent my spleen, he hung up. 1471 was dialed, and it was a withheld number. I wonder if it was the bloke Paul was talking about?
19th January 2010 at 6:58 pm
Hi Paul,
that certainly sounds like a very demoralising company to work for especially as your offer was a good one. It’s unfortunate that a few bad companies give the profession a bad reputation, I do know of telesales companies that are ethical and customer focused.
I’m guessing that you’ve now left that company and glad to put it behind you. At least you know how NOT to treat prospects and customers !
18th January 2010 at 8:24 pm
Hi,
I worked for a telesales company offering right hand side google listings to small to medium sized-businesses.
The manager was this twitching, foul-mouthed Mancunian who sweated an incredible amount and was really abusive to his staff members. He used to ‘motivate’ the telesales staff by shouting at them and telling them that they were ‘grovelling pieces of shit that need not have bothered getting out of bed in the morning.’
We were all employed on a commission-only wage and although what we were offering was legit and to some extent and purpose was effective for our clients, (we would check after to see if the companies we signed up got listed, and many of them repeat-subscripted) the emphasis was always to get the sale on the first call, never allow the potential customer to ‘think it over’….in fact belittle them if they even suggested it.
We could not send an email, fax information, the company did not even have a website!! – how unimpressive is that for a company that claims to offer an IT service to other businesses?!
After the standard script was used by the telesales staff there were no limits to what we could say in order to get the sale. We could promise exclusivity, that their search criteria could not be offered to anyone else for a minimum period of a year. What’s told over the phone and what binds in a legal written contract are two very different things.
We were told to ask for the sale three times before hanging up and moving onto the next call. In other words if we were not being pushy to the point of almost being rude we were not doing our job! So much for emapthy selling or allowing the product to sell itself – just be pushy – just ask, how would you like to pay? Visa or Mastercard?
Unfortunately this is just the sad, sorry state of the telesales profession in this country – the company may offer a professional service, but the short-sighted ego and substance addictions of the middle/top-end management are the driving force behind these organisations and their dated sales techniques.
11th September 2009 at 11:16 am
Jimmy
Good point about the caller’s attitude – it certainly did not give any sense of confidence or trust in what he was offering.
Incidentally – he never did call back! I wonder why?
Carol
10th September 2009 at 10:26 pm
I have worked as the main decision maker (regarding ecommerce and marketing spend) within a SME for 2 years now and previously held similar roles elsewhere.
I get 1 or 2 of these calls a day, I even get people calling me up telling me that they are calling on behalf of google or are google.
While you can quite easily get an account manager at google they will not make such promises.
I wouldnt think too much of this and there are products out there that will preobably get you onto the 1st page very quickly (using a form of authorised parasite hosting) but I wouldnt deal with these guys just because of their attitude.
29th July 2009 at 10:41 pm
Hi Jonathan,
you are spot on – and it is especially irksome to see the less internet savvy business owners being conned into parting with large sums of money for unrealistic promises that cannot be kept.
28th July 2009 at 12:53 pm
The other main thing to watch for is companies that make promises on systems they cannot control, like Google.
No-one, except Google can guarantee certain placements. A good SEO company can certainly get you ranked a lot higher, but there are no guarantees – if your competitors are doing the same.
There are also SEO ‘professionals’ who think that just submitting sites to search engines is SEO – given that most search engines will find your site naturally pretty quickly (as long as there is one outside link) this does not help – google even say on their site there is no point in resubmitting a site that is already listed.
29th March 2009 at 7:23 am
Thanks for the heads up
16th February 2009 at 8:24 am
I doubt it was a phishing deal. Just a really lousy and inaccurate sales pitch. It’s undoubtedly a den of thieves, but I doubt they’re churning and burning with stolen card numbers. Just soaking those who might not know better. What rats!
13th February 2009 at 6:08 pm
Hi Mark,
I’ve come across this ‘sharp practice’ before where a publication for a ‘charity’ claims you’ve agreed to advertise / be in a printed book or similar. I don’t think it is the charity themselves doing it but the company producing the publication (I may be wrong, if anyone knows for sure please add a comment).
Are you a member of the Federation of Small Businesses (FSB)? If so, I suggest you call the free legal help line and ask for their advice about this. Then, hopefully, they will be able to put your mind at rest.
Carol
13th February 2009 at 12:28 pm
Hi Carol,
My company Bistro L!VE operate live music restaurants in the Midlands, and we regularly contribute a table for 6 or 10 people for schools to help them raise cash.
I received a call yesterday from a Stephanie from “The Children’s Fundraising Campaign” to let me know that the books that our kind donation had bought were now ready to be sent to the school of our choice. They were all nicely printed up with the Bistro L!VE logo, and all we had to do was to choose a school to benefit – did I have one in mind?
I was very busy at the time (writing the copy for our March birthday mailer), so was only really listening with one ear. I said, no you choose, and she said, OK we will just pick a school that is close to the postcode of your business in Leicester – is that OK? I said fine. She then said, (and this is the killer, sucker punch), OK, where do you want me to send the invoice for £199.00 for this.
I then started to ‘smell a rat’. I said to her that I felt she was employing extremely sharp sales practices, as I had never agreed to this. She said that according to her notes, she had spoken to me 2 weeks earlier, and I had agreed to this, and on the strength of this they had ordered the specially designed (and bespoke to Bistro L!VE) books. I said that this was not true, and the conversation ‘to’d and fro’d for another few minutes or so.
Anyway, the upshot was that I said to her, let me have your business details, name address, tel no etc, and I will speak to Trading Standards about what they were doing. She finished by saying that they had a good relationship with Trading Standards, and then hung up!
The fear I have is that she may well have me on a recording saying “fine” to sending the books to a school of her choice, and may use this to infer that I ‘agreed’ to the sale!
The thing is, this is not the first time that we have seen this sort of scam – the same thing happened with an American company selling till rolls – they just ring up all matter of fact, and say “we are just about to despatch your latest order of till rolls that your Head Office ordered – is that OK?” They then ask your name, and BINGO – you’ve said it’s OK, and they have your name !
13th February 2009 at 12:08 pm
Hi Nigel,
yes I’ve heard about the domain name scam before.
The problem with our modern world is everything moves so fast it is difficult for business people to keep on top of everything that is going on. And the con merchants take advantage of that.
I guess there’s always been confidence tricksters, just that now there’s more opportunities for them to do the cons.
We just have to be more vigilant and wary – see the comments from Alan Jones in the post following this one.
Carol
12th February 2009 at 7:44 pm
Hi Carol
Sounds like a scam of some description. The only way I’m aware of have exclusive rights to PPC phrases is if the phrase is a registered trademark and you own the trademark.
If you search on Luftwaffe Collectibles there’s more than one PPC ad on Google, which doesn’t tie in with the sales patter.
Also had a couple of clients have a phone call saying someone is trying to register a domain name with a variation of their company name and offering to protect it for a huge amount. The caller is well informed about the company and location and very specific about the person who is trying to register the domain name.
It angers me there are people out there doing this.
Grrr!!!
Regards
Nigel